The Diaper Dilemma

Can you calculate your baby’s carbon butt-print? Here’s help deciding which method is right for your family—cloth or disposable

If green is the new black, baby diapers are anything but stylish.It turns out that all diapering choices—cloth, disposable, and hybrid—come with potential problems for Mother Earth.  Because no method is absolutely environmentally friendly, the quandary persists: WASH OR TOSS?

Unfortunately, science hasn’t yet settled the debate.  Until recently, studies on the environmental impact of diapers were funded by either the disposable or cloth-diaper industries.  The results were predictably biased, and each side of the argument called foul.

The United Kingdom broke this trend with a 2005 study from The Environment Agency, a British government bureau.It found virtually no difference between the environmental effects of cloth and disposable diapers.  In fact, the authors wrote, “For one child, over two and a half years, these impacts are roughly comparable with driving a car between 1,300 and 2,200 miles.” Issue settled, right?  Not so fast.  A Dutch study completed in 2007 concluded that cloth diapers are as much as seven times better for the environment than conventional disposable diapers.

Confused?  It’s no wonder.  But it all boils down to this: Washing cloth diapers consumes water.  Conventional diapers take up landfill space.  And even new hybrid products have potential problems.

While expecting her first child in 2007, Alex Kennaugh faced this problem head-on.As director of the Natural Resources Defense Council’s Green Living program, she talked to water consumption specialists, scientists studying the effects of chemicals in laundry detergents, and landfill experts.  But she had no moment when the heavens opened revealing a ray of light shining on the perfect diaper.  “There never seemed to be a clear answer about environmental effects of diapers—what was better or worse,” she says.

Let’s review the data, shall we?

DISPOSABLE

Before her daughter, Quinn, was born in 2007, Stephanie Wood didn’t give diapers much thought.  “There was too much else to research,” the Shamong, NJ , public relations professional says.  Quinn was born early—at a tiny 5 pounds, 6 ounces—and only preemie disposable diapers fit her.After Quinn gained some w eight, Wood searched for greener options, and that’s when her head began to spin.

“Is it six of one, half-a-dozen of the other?  I just had to make a decision,” she says.  “Diapers shouldn’t be that big of a deal, but they were.” After a failed trial run with hybrids, Wood finally gave in to conventional disposables.  “We had the best intentions,” she says.

Wood shouldn’t have worried about it, says Carlos Richer, founder of Richer Investment Diaper Consulting Services, a Mexico-based company that advises the disposable diaper industry.  Design improvements mean that parents are using fewer diapers each day.  And besides, he agrees with The Environment Agency study: Between conventional disposables and cloth diapers, the environmental differences are a wash.

But there is no denying the fact that disposable diapers are not particularly Earth-friendly.  There are several significant issues to consider: production, distribution, packaging, and disposal.

The main components of most conventional disposable diapers are a polyethylene film, which can be made to look and feel like cloth; a cellulose pad; and sodium polyacrylate or super-absorbent polymer (SAP).Manufacturing conventional diapers produces air and water pollution.  In addition, trees are felled to make the cellulose pads, and the plastics are made with non-renewable oil.

Of course, disposable diapers don’t magically appear on our s tore shelves.  Transporting merchandise requires gallons of gasoline, using more resources and polluting the air.Because disposables are one languish in a landfill for longer than you might think.Landfills are not designed to help further the degradation process.  “Even a banana peel— you’re not 100 percent sure that it will biodegrade in every landfill,” Richer says.

CLOTH

So if disposable diapers are bad for that many aspects of the environment, cloth must be the answer, right?  Not quite.  The potential problem with cloth is three-fold—cotton production, as well as water and energy use.

“Cotton is the most pesticide-reliant crop in the world, by far,” says Steve Scholl-Buckwald, managing director of Pesticide Action Network North America.  About 10 percent of all pesticides and 25 percent of all insecticides are used on cotton crops.  To reduce the use of these toxins, the cotton industry introduced genetically modified cotton, which poses its own problems, such as resistance to certain bacteria.

In addition, cotton is a thirsty plant.  That’s not usually an issue in places like Georgia, where rainfall is sufficient.  But cotton is a popular crop in western states and countries such as Uzbekistan, where the Aral Sea has been all but eradicated by crop irrigation.  That’s why Scholl-Buckwald recommends choosing organic cotton, hemp, or bamboo diapers.  And that’s never been easier for parents.  “The baby market [for these fabrics] is huge,” he says.

Bethany Dias of Raleigh, NC, found another option: “I’ve made all of my diapers out of reused materials,” she says.  Dias has also committed to reducing energy and water consumption that comes with washing loads of diapers each week.  She’s estimated that her front-load washer helps reduce water consumption by 20 percent.  And to conserve energy, she air-dries diapers.

On the other hand, diaper services present unique environmental problems.  First, larger washing machines typically use mor e energy and water.  Diaper services also pick up and deliver the diapers, which takes fuel.Even without a diaper service, green blogger Kathleen Ridihalgh of Sea ttle found cloth diapering her 2 year old to be a lot easier than she expected.  “It just became the way life was,” she says.

HybriD

If washing loads of diapers isn’t your thing and you’re not sold on conventional diapers, the hybrid may be your best option.  Usually made of cloth covers with flushable inserts, hybrids offer the best of both worlds, while avoiding some of the environmental pitfalls.  “You’re putting poop where poop belongs,” Gavigan says.He chose hybrid diapers when his son Luke was born.  “They were hard to use at the beginning, but after one or two months, we were cruising along.”

Ideally, only the insert is soiled, which means that the cloth pant can be reused several times before washing.  But having enough on hand seems to be the key.  Wood gave up on them when her daughter wet through both pairs during the day.Gavigan keeps a stash of about eight hybrid cloth pants.

Parents with low-flow toilets or who have sensitive septic tanks ma y find that flushing the inserts may not be possible.  Breaking up the insert and swishing it around in the toilet can help, but that is not f or everyone.Still hybrid proponents insist that these diapers are a great option, even if the biodegradable inserts are thrown away.

THE BOTTOM LINE

There’s no magical answer to the diaper dilemma.  Whether cloth or disposable or hybrid, diapering our babies’ bottoms does have an environmental impact.  “Being a mom and a dad, there are a lot of compromises, and there’s a lot of sacrifice,” Gavigan says.  But we can also ease up on our personal expectations.  “Not being super critical is an important thing about being a parent.” Kennaugh agrees.  “It doesn’t have to be a Sophie’s choice,” she says.  “I’m all for convenience for moms.”

Laura Laing’s writing has appeared in Parents and The Advocate.  She’s hoping that by the time she has another child, the diaper debate will be settled once and for all—but she’s not holding her breath.

THE BACK STORY

1887

First mass-produced cloth diaper introduced in the U.S.

1940’s

Diaper services become popular

1942

First disposable diaper— a cellulose pad secured with rubber pants— manufactured in Sweden

1950’s

Kendall, Parke-Davis, and Playtex roll out their own versions of the disposable diaper

1961

Pampers enters the market

1980’s

Environmental organizations begin advocating for a return to cloth diapers

1990’s

Disposable diapers are used by 95 percent of U.S. parents

2003

Small cloth-diaper companies crop up from the sewing rooms of moms throughout the country

2006

The first hybrid diaper is introduced in the U.S.

SOURCE: DIAPERJUNGLE.COM AND MOTHER JONES

 

– Laura Liang